To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
This cover perfectly fits our smaller Ducane Grill. The grill itself is pretty old, but it has held up well, and we hope to keep it going because it is the only size that works on our small patio. The CoverMates cover that we bought 4 years ago recently ripped out, and it was dismaying to see that a replacement for it would cost $65, plus shipping. This one cost half that much, and It is thicker. Because it is lined with a water resistant material, it is stiffer and not quite as easy to pull on and off as the CoverMates, however it may last longer. It takes a beating out in the sun and weather all day, every day. Only had it a few weeks now, so I can't rate its durability. This was from Amazon Warehouse (used), more likely it was returned. I would have ordered a new one, but this "used" one was the only one in the size I needed, so I took a risk. It was perfectly fine. Super bargain.
I first purchased one medium and it extended to the floor. I returned and got the small and it fits EXACTLY as the picture. This is great craftmanship, does not rip easily (I am not very careful) and looks very professional.